As part of my tear sheet organizing project, I'm making my way through some back issues. A few of the Architectural Digests - including the February 2009 issue - hadn't even gotten the first look. So imagine what I'm thinking as I read this letter from the editor:
"So you think you can decorate? You probably can't. Think you have great taste? You probably don't. Think you have style? Think again. So what is this rant about? Two things. One, let the decorator do it. Let the architect do it. They have created hundreds, perhaps thousands, of rooms. How many have you done? Don't delude yourself. They can do it better."
"Now I'm going to seem to contradict myself. It may be true that you want to do your own home your way, regardless of what anyone may think and regardless of whether it's 'good design.' Well, you're right, too. My other point? Do it the way that's comfortable for you."
"Now, how to resolve these seemingly conflicting viewpoints? It's fairly simple. Some people really care about a beautifully designed residence. Others don't. Perhaps you're not particularly visual and are convinced you pay no attention to your surroundings. Wrong. You do. Even if you're not consciously aware of it, you're affected by colors, scale and lighting, by furniture and whatever is on your walls. So maybe you don't 'have taste' or even have 'bad taste.' So what? It's not a character flaw."
"Perhaps the theme of this letter is this. Do what you want to do in your own home. As I mentioned earlier, a professional decorator can create an interior space that reflects and complements you and may even improve the way you feel and the way you live. A fine architect or interior designer will almost certainly enrich your life and subtly allow your best self to come forth. The really interesting idea is how people choose to live. Some homes are photogenic, perfect to be featured in a magazine. (This one, for instance.) Some are not. Both are cherished by those who live in them."
"And that's the way it should be."
- Paige Rense, Editor-in-Chief
Meow! Hiss! I see a catfight brewing, because it takes a lot of nerve to write that ... even if she does believe it. I would paraphrase Paige's statement like this - "if you hired a top architect and designer to do your home, great; it must be fabulous ... maybe even fabulous enough for Architectural Digest. If not, I'm sorry, but it is most certainly atrocious. But if you are comfortable there (cough, cough, clearing of throat), good for you. I'm glad not everyone cares about how they live."
I think her comments are a touch arrogant and more than a bit obnoxious. Am I being too harsh? I'd love to hear what you think. As for me, while I love a beautiful environment, I prefer Coco Chanel's philosophy: "It's not houses I love; it's the life I live in them." Now that is a woman with the right attitude.